Conflict management: How leaders can handle disagreement well
Managing conflict well takes more than good intentions. It requires leaders to recognise when something isn't right, understand the perspectives involved and create the conditions for a constructive conversation.
How should leaders manage conflict?
There is no script or blueprint that will resolve every difficult situation. But there are some habits that make these conversations considerably more productive.

Deal with it early
Leaders often know that something is wrong before anyone says so.
The atmosphere in meetings changes or two people stop speaking directly to each other. Someone who was previously engaged becomes noticeably withdrawn and small disagreements keep resurfacing.
It is tempting to wait for clearer evidence, however that can be a mistake.
Acas's research found that unresolved conflict can remain latent and resurface later. It also found that informal discussion is by far the most common way people attempt to resolve workplace conflict.
Early intervention does not mean making every disagreement into a formal issue. Often it is simply a conversation:
"I've noticed there seems to be some tension between you. Is there something we need to talk about?"
That may be enough to bring something into the open before it becomes harder to address.
Listen before deciding who is right
One of the easiest mistakes for a leader to make is to walk into a difficult conversation having already decided what happened.
There are usually at least two versions of the story.
Give people the opportunity to explain what they experienced, what they were trying to achieve and where they think the problem lies. That does not mean accepting everything they say as fact. It means gathering enough information to understand the situation properly.
Questions such as these can help:
-
"Talk me through what happened from your perspective."
-
"What were you trying to achieve?"
-
"What do you think the other person sees differently?"
-
"What do you think is causing the difficulty?"
-
"What would you like to see happen instead?"
Listening is not the same as agreeing and it is much harder to resolve a problem you have not properly understood.
Keep the conversation about behaviour and impact
Conflict becomes much harder to resolve when people start talking about personality.
"He's impossible."
"She never listens."
"They are deliberately undermining me."
Those statements may reflect how someone feels, but they are not particularly useful starting points for resolving the problem.
Bring the conversation back to what actually happened and what effect it had.
Instead of saying, "You keep undermining the team," a leader might say:
"We've agreed this decision twice, but it has subsequently been reopened with the team. Can we talk about why that is happening?"
That leaves room for an explanation. It also makes it possible to change the behaviour without requiring either person to defend their character.
Look beneath the argument
The issue being discussed is not always the issue causing the conflict and like in medicine, to create a sustainable solution itβs vital to understand the cause rather than just addressing the symptoms.
Ask yourself what might be sitting underneath the disagreement.
Is someone worried about losing control? Has trust been damaged? Does one person feel that their contribution is not being recognised? Are responsibilities unclear? Is there an assumption about the other person's intentions that nobody has tested?
A useful question in a difficult conversation is:
"What is this really about?"
Sometimes that is where the conversation finally becomes useful.
Make it safe to disagree
There is an important distinction between psychological safety and simply making people feel comfortable.
Psychological safety is about whether people believe they can take interpersonal risks β for example, admitting a mistake, asking a question or challenging an idea β without being humiliated or punished for doing so. Amy Edmondson's foundational research connected psychological safety with learning behaviour in teams, and subsequent research has continued to explore its relationship with leadership, learning and organisational performance. Institute members can further develop their understanding of psychological safety through the learning modules in MyLeadership+.
If people believe disagreement will be held against them, they are less likely to raise it.
That does not mean every challenge should be accepted or every view treated as equally valid. It means people should be able to say "I don't agree" without feeling that they have put themselves at risk.
As leaders it is important to recognise that if we respond defensively to challenge it may unintentionally teach the team not to challenge at all.
Be clear about what happens next
A conversation can feel productive and still achieve very little.
Before it ends, make sure there is some clarity about what happens next.
Perhaps someone needs to change a behaviour. Perhaps a decision needs to be made. Perhaps responsibilities need to be clarified. Perhaps two people simply need to agree how they will communicate differently.
The important thing is to be specific and then follow up.
That follow-up should be light-touch at least initially. A week or two later, ask how things are going. This is important not because the situation needs to be monitored indefinitely, but because changing an established pattern rarely happens after one conversation alone.
When should conflict be escalated?
Unfortunately not every conflict can or should be dealt with informally.
There are circumstances where formal organisational processes may be appropriate.
The important point is not to confuse informal conflict management with avoiding formal action.
Mediation can be useful in some situations, particularly where relationships have broken down or people are struggling to work together. CIPD describes mediation as a voluntary process involving an impartial third party and stresses that it is most effective when conflict is addressed early. The current Acas consultation is looking at the role of mediation alongside other proposed changes to its guidance.
However, mediation is not appropriate in every situation, particularly where serious allegations are involved and leaders need enough judgement to recognise the difference.
Sometimes the right response is a conversation between the people involved. Sometimes HR needs to be brought in, and sometimes a formal process is necessary.
Knowing which is which is part of the job of every leader.
Five questions to ask when conflict arises
When faced with a difficult situation, five questions can provide a useful pause before jumping into action:
What do I actually know?
Separate what has happened from what you think has happened.
What is the disagreement really about?
The presenting issue may not be the underlying one.
What part might I have played?
Consider whether your own decisions, communication or inaction have contributed.
What conversation needs to happen?
If something needs to be said, avoiding it rarely makes it easier.
What needs to change afterwards?
Be clear about the practical outcome you are looking for.
They are simple questions which is part of their value.
The aim isn't to eliminate conflict
Leadership is sometimes presented as the ability to keep everyone aligned, but the reality is that alignment does not require uniformity.
People will see things differently and they will challenge decisions. They will occasionally get frustrated with each other and that is part of working in any organisation where people have different responsibilities and perspectives.
The leadership test is what happens next.
Do people feel able to raise the disagreement? Can they challenge an idea without attacking the person? Can the leader intervene without immediately taking sides? And when a decision is made, can everyone move forward even if they did not get the outcome they wanted?
Those are more useful measures of a healthy team than the complete absence of disagreement.
The crucial point for leaders to remember is that conflict management is less about having the perfect technique and more about having the confidence to recognise a problem, understand what is driving it and have the conversation that needs to happen.
There are times when that conversation will be uncomfortable but it is still usually better to have it than to avoid addressing the situation.