Don't wait for Acas: Why workplace relationships are a leadership issue

The Acas Early Conciliation changes on 26th November raise a question that goes well beyond procedure: are we giving managers the skills and confidence to deal with workplace problems early?

Annette Wade-Clarke, The Institute of Leadership’s Interim Managing Director, explores why leaders and organisational culture have a crucial role to play.

By the time a grievance reaches HR, the people involved may have been living with the problem for months. Maybe it stems from a decision that was badly explained, or someone tried to raise a concern and felt brushed off. It could have been that a manager meant to have a conversation but kept putting it off because it was uncomfortable. However, we reach a point where neither side is willing to give much ground.

When I talk to people about these situations, it always strikes me that very often there was a chance to intervene earlier. When I say intervene, I don’t mean making the disagreement disappear, but to listen, explain a decision or address behaviour before the relationship broke down.

That is why the changes to Acas Early Conciliation coming into effect on 26th November can’t just be placed at the HR team’s door because they deserve real leadership attention.

A manager talks openly with a colleague across a table during a one-to-one meeting.

In terms of the changes, individuals contacting Acas about a potential employment tribunal claim will be asked for more detail, including what the issue is, whether it is ongoing and whether they have raised it with their employer.

Employers need to be aware of a change in how Acas contacts them. Where Acas considers that settlement is not possible, it will no longer be required to make reasonable attempts to contact the employer, even where the individual has consented to contact.

The 12-week early conciliation period remains unchanged; however, employers may have fewer opportunities to hear about a potential dispute through Acas before a claim progresses.

It is of course absolutely the case that HR teams will need to understand these practical changes. For me, though, they bring us back to something much more fundamental - we should not need an external process to find out that a working relationship in our own organisation has broken down.

The conversations that never happen

There are times when the backstory to a grievance is pretty straightforward. The scenario could be that a manager has struggled to address someone’s behaviour, or an employee has questioned a decision and never had a proper explanation.

At the other end of the scale there are situations that are harder to untangle. An example could be the fact that two colleagues have been falling out for so long that neither can remember where it started. Or a manager is increasingly frustrated with someone’s performance but has not said so directly or taken steps to address the issue. It could be that an employee feels they are being treated differently from everyone else, and nobody has asked why.

I’ve seen how ordinary workplace issues grow when people avoid these types of conversations. One universal truth in these situations is that delaying makes the next conversation harder, particularly if someone has already tried to speak up and feels ignored. By the time a formal complaint is made, several chances to handle things differently may have passed because a sense of injustice has been allowed to fester.

I do want to be clear that this doesn't mean that I believe that every disagreement can be resolved over a cup of coffee, or that formal grievance procedures aren't necessary. Some situations require a formal response from the outset, and employees must also be able to raise concerns that they feel are serious without being pressured into informal resolution.

Of course, even a genuine attempt to talk things through will not always be met with a willingness to engage. That is separate from the merits of the concern, or someone’s right to raise it formally, but it is a reminder that managers cannot make a constructive conversation happen on their own.

A fair, robust grievance process is crucial. However, ensuring that managers recognise when they need to act, rather than leaving a problem to drift until that process is the only option, is just as important.

That work has to happen inside the organisation, whether or not Acas ever gets involved.

HR cannot be everywhere

Policies on grievances, bullying, harassment and conduct give employers a framework to work within, and HR brings the professional advice needed to apply it fairly. However, it does not matter how tight our policies are or how brilliant our HR teams are at supporting us; either can substitute for what a manager does in the moment.

An employee challenges a decision in a meeting. Someone makes an inappropriate remark. A member of the team asks for a private conversation. How the manager responds tells people whether they can speak openly and what behaviour will be tolerated.

People remember those responses, especially when they sit uneasily alongside the organisation’s stated values.

If an employee who delivers good results is allowed to behave badly, colleagues notice. If a manager repeatedly avoids difficult conversations, the team learns to work around the problem. Over time, keeping quiet can begin to feel like the safest option.

HR should be there to advise, keep processes fair and consistent, and help managers through difficult situations, but it cannot and should not manage every working relationship on their behalf.

Managers have to take responsibility for those relationships, with support and clear expectations from the leaders who appoint them.

When the same problems recur across different teams, leaders need to ask what they are doing to address them. Are managers getting the support they need? Is poor behaviour being challenged, or quietly accepted?

The fact is that this is where organisational culture actually takes shape. It’s not in a values statement, but in the decisions people see being made and the behaviour they learn to expect from one another.

Good at the job, new to managing people

It is easy to see why someone who is experienced, capable and delivering results gets promoted into management. What is less clear is why we sometimes expect them to know how to do it from day one.

They may be entirely comfortable allocating work and keeping a project on track, but much less sure how to tell a colleague that their behaviour is upsetting the team. Being promoted to management does not automatically come with the ability to know how to handle this type of situation, and putting ‘manager’ in someone’s job title does not magically make that difficult conversation any easier.

I think something important that we can often miss when we are helping new managers to develop is understanding how they come across. I’m a communications person by trade, so it’s something I quickly notice, and it often prickles me. There’s no winner in these scenarios because what feels like a direct answer to a manager can feel dismissive or intimidating to the person hearing it, and without useful feedback about their delivery style, the manager may never realise there is a problem.

I also don’t think that we can avoid the F-word when we’re thinking about how these situations occur in the first place. We have to understand the part that fear plays. A manager may worry about saying the wrong thing, making matters worse or getting something wrong from an employment perspective. It’s understandable that doing nothing can feel less risky and that passing everything to HR can feel safer still.

We have to acknowledge that we ask managers to deal with all kinds of sensitive situations, often with surprisingly little preparation. Giving someone a policy to read is useful, but it will not help them practise what to say when a conversation becomes tense, or an employee is visibly upset.

I do think it’s important to be clear that this is not just a ‘new manager’ issue because experience alone is no guarantee, either. I’ve seen numerous examples of people who have been managing for 10, 15, 20 years or more without ever improving the way they give feedback or handle conflict.

We expect people in our organisation to keep their professional knowledge and skills up to date. It doesn’t matter whether they’re an accountant, an IT professional, a marketeer, an engineer or any other trade or profession. I think sometimes we forget that managing people deserves the same commitment to ongoing learning.

Leadership development is part of the answer

Leadership development is often discussed in terms of succession planning or preparing people for senior roles. I would like us to give more attention to the manager who needs help with a difficult conversation this week.

That might mean practising how to give unwelcome feedback, challenge behaviour or let someone explain a concern without becoming defensive. Managers also need judgement because they need to be confident in when they can deal with something themselves, and when they should seek specialist advice.

We absolutely do not need all of our managers to become employment law experts, but they do need to feel able to initiate a conversation, address issues, and know where to turn when they need help.

Attending a one-off course or listening to a briefing when legislation changes are valuable for managers. However, the harder work comes afterwards, when someone tries a different approach, reflects on how it went and has another opportunity to practise.

Professional leadership learning gives managers space to do that beyond the immediate demands of the job, rather than only thinking about their development when something has gone wrong.

Professional recognition can support that, too. Being part of a professional body offers access to learning, resources and a wider community of people interested in developing their practice. At the Institute of Leadership, members can access MyLeadership+, our online learning platform, with practical modules covering subjects such as Difficult Conversations, Giving and Receiving Feedback, Evaluating Team Performance and Personal Leadership Development.

The value of that learning is in what managers can put to use with their teams.

I think as leaders we need to be more attuned to the fact that the cost of getting this wrong is not confined to a formal dispute. A poorly handled disagreement takes up management and HR time, draws in colleagues and can leave good employees wondering whether to stay. When there is a grievance in many cases, even once the original issue is settled, the working relationship may not recover.

It would be very naive to think that better management will not prevent every dispute. There are situations when it won’t. However, giving people a better chance of being heard and of dealing with a problem before it becomes entrenched certainly isn’t going to make situations worse.

What happens before the next grievance?

There is practical work for organisations to do ahead of 26th November. They need to understand the revised Acas process, update HR teams and make sure managers know how to raise concerns and get advice. Alongside that, I would ask leaders to look at the support their managers receive now.

Can a manager talk through a difficult situation with someone before deciding what to do? Do they get useful feedback on how they manage people? When a problem keeps resurfacing, does anyone ask why? Those answers may tell us more than a record of who has completed a course.

There will always be grievances and employment disputes, and some concerns need a formal response from the outset. This is not an argument for keeping problems away from HR. It is an argument for making sure managers know when and how to act, with HR’s support.

The Acas changes will not fix a difficult working relationship. The manager who has been putting off a conversation still has to have it. I would like us to spend as much time helping them prepare for that conversation as we spend preparing for what happens if it never takes place.